« Crowd Control | Main | The Great Global Warming Swindle »

A Physics of Society: Critical Mass Notes #1

Ton has written an elegant post about the value of maths in the design of social tools. It reminded me of a book by Philip Ball called Critical Mass, and I realised how little I could really remember of it other than the broad brush strokes.

So I thought I'd reread it and post some notes.

1: Raising Leviathan

  • The Scientific Revolution did not just affect the sciences. It affected politics too.
  • Various thinkers, such as More, Grotius and Bacon began to imagine societies based on scientific reasoning. They were "Utopians"; in many ways descendants of Plato in that they gathered some first principles, and tried to deduce what sort of societies would work given those principles
  • Hobbes was an especially mechanistic Utopian. He fell in love with geometry and the way mathematicians could build on simple assumptions to find more complex, and sometimes surprising truths.
  • With his Leviathan, he aimed for
    "a theory of governance as unimpeachable as those of Euclid's geometry".
  • Traces of his approach can be found in Adam Smith, Jeremy Bentham, John Stuart Mill, Karl Marx and other political theorists.
  • That's one trajectory, but it's not particularly scientific one.
    "Political theorists tend to concern themselves with what they think ought to be; scientists concentrate on the way things are
  • "There are few political thinkers who have defined a social model with the logical precision of Hobbes, and none who have carried those precepts through to their conclusions in a truly scientific way."
  • Physicists have developed tools since then that, however unintentionally, add rigour to the sorts of scientific models a modern day Hobbes might want. The same tools that allow physicists to understand the behaviour of atoms can be used to begin to model the behaviour of people.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)